If one is a proud progressive or liberal, as this blogger is, it is hard not to be squirming today as one contemplates the likelihood of two major setbacks for the progressive movement in America this week from the United States Supreme Court.
The majority of experts and prognosticators forecast a 5-4 vote against the Affordable Care Act and for the Arizona immigration law restrictions.
Both such events would be terrible setbacks, and hard to overcome in the short run for sure, and probably in the long run as well.
Some say a defeat on the Obama Health Care law would lead ultimately to Medicare for all within a couple of years, and that defeat on the Arizona SB 1070 would lead to comprehensive immigration reform within two years, as well.
But all that only seems possible IF the Democrats win both houses of Congress and the Presidency again in November.
The theory is that two defeats administered by the right wing Supreme Court by 5-4 margins, on top of the Citizens United case and the Bush V. Gore case of twelve years ago would so galvanize the American people, who are progressives, to organize, unify, vote en masse to promote the necessary changes.
But when one considers the great edge financially that the right wing has with billionaires ready to spend hundreds of millions of dollars individually to back Mitt Romney and the Republican Party in Congress, including the Koch Brothers and Sheldon Adelson among others, one has to wonder if even such organization and unity and discipline by progressives will be enough, particularly when added to the active campaigns of Republican Governors to purge the voting rolls, and defy the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
One can hope for the best on all fronts, but it is hard not to be pessimistic and a bit depressed on this Sunday before the storm likely to erupt this week, by a one vote margin created by the outrage of George W. Bush being selected President over Al Gore a dozen years ago, and still reverberating in 2012 and, likely, beyond!
Professor, it’s always darkest before the dawn as they say. I love the first line of the attached linked column:
“The test of a first rate intelligence is the ability to hold two oppossed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function”.
—F. Scott Fitzgerald
While the attached column is more a comment on the Massachusetts judicial system, there are similarities in the thought process and a great civics lesson in the commentary.
http://www.bostonherald.com/news/opinion/op_ed/view/20220624scales_of_justice_must_balance_independence_accountability/